Wine#1
Very light red colour and typical Pinot nose with lots of red berries and chocolate.
Simple, but attractive taste.
A great lunch wine that should go well with white meat.
Panel took one sniff of the glass and said Pinot from California.
Pinot Noir, Hirsch vineyard, San Andreas Fault, Sonoma Coast.
Score 16,80
Hirsch Vineyards
Wine #2
Another Pinot Noir, but this has more color and structure.
Darker berries with dark chocolate.
A powerful Pinot from perhaps a cooler climate.
Soft integrated tanins and a lovely big taste.
Panel in no doubt about grape. Some discussions around Cali vs NZ..
Pinot Noir 2006, Marimar Estate, Russian River (Cali), oh we like it!
Score 17.70
Marimar Estate
Wine #3
Another Pinot with lovely smell of red berries, flowers and vanilla.
Taste is slightly "cooked" which leads parts of the panel to even warmer climates than California (how is that possible).
The wine lacks acidity and is a bit dull.
The wine turns out to be Beaune 1er cru 2007 which is a "cold" year and in recent tastings it was totally different...(wineshop problem..?)
Beaune 1er "Boucherottes", Anne Gros, 2007, Score 16,60 (previous 18)
Wine # 4
Deep dark red coloured wine.
Lots of dark berries (forrest).
Big solid smooth taste packed with alcohol.
Panel not sure about the Pinot track and dithers around.
Probably a new world wine but ...
Stags Leap Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 "Artemis" Napa Valley, Score 18,70
(how did it get such a high score...)
Stags Leap - The Estate
Very light red colour and typical Pinot nose with lots of red berries and chocolate.
Simple, but attractive taste.
A great lunch wine that should go well with white meat.
Panel took one sniff of the glass and said Pinot from California.
Pinot Noir, Hirsch vineyard, San Andreas Fault, Sonoma Coast.
Score 16,80
Hirsch Vineyards
Wine #2
Another Pinot Noir, but this has more color and structure.
Darker berries with dark chocolate.
A powerful Pinot from perhaps a cooler climate.
Soft integrated tanins and a lovely big taste.
Panel in no doubt about grape. Some discussions around Cali vs NZ..
Pinot Noir 2006, Marimar Estate, Russian River (Cali), oh we like it!
Score 17.70
Marimar Estate
Wine #3
Another Pinot with lovely smell of red berries, flowers and vanilla.
Taste is slightly "cooked" which leads parts of the panel to even warmer climates than California (how is that possible).
The wine lacks acidity and is a bit dull.
The wine turns out to be Beaune 1er cru 2007 which is a "cold" year and in recent tastings it was totally different...(wineshop problem..?)
Beaune 1er "Boucherottes", Anne Gros, 2007, Score 16,60 (previous 18)
Wine # 4
Deep dark red coloured wine.
Lots of dark berries (forrest).
Big solid smooth taste packed with alcohol.
Panel not sure about the Pinot track and dithers around.
Probably a new world wine but ...
Stags Leap Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 "Artemis" Napa Valley, Score 18,70
(how did it get such a high score...)
Stags Leap - The Estate
Comments